Risk is Defined by 4 Words

spiral, staircase

This is more or less Part Dos of the risk framework I shared last year with my buddy Benjamin. What LPs define as risk when investing in GPs. This one, unlike the last, is my own Shakespearean (or lack thereof) interpretation. How I underwrite risk in GPs. So, a/ this is not the Bible, b/ use your own best judgment, c/ if you don’t know where to start, hopefully this serves as inspiration.

After I read the deck and meet with a GP once, I write a list of all the risks I can think of about said GP. Then I stack rank them in the order of most to least important (to me). Obviously a subjective take. Then draw a line in there that determines the least amount of risk I’m willing to tolerate before investing. Then I do references and homework to see if I can alleviate the top risks of investing. Sometimes that means more conversations with the GP. Sometimes that means talking to others. Other times, it’s just something I have to wrestle with internally.

Admittedly, most of the time, if it’s something I have to figure out myself if I can accept the risk(s), I don’t invest. It either means I should have drawn that line higher up or it means diligence unveiled more complexity than I anticipated, which leads me to something I read recently.

Jerry Neumann wrote a phenomenal article on Colossus the past week, titled “Venture is Dead (Again).” To which, I highly recommend a read. A mini history lesson mixed with stark reality of today. Above all, the line that resonated the most with me is:

Frank Knight, one of the earliest economic theorists of entrepreneurship, introduced the idea of uncertainty: risk is when you know the odds, uncertainty is when you do not. Regular companies face risk. Startups face uncertainty. When there is certainty, there are bank loans. When there is risk, there is the stock market and private equity. But when there is true uncertaintyโ€”when a company is predicated on something that is simply not yet knowableโ€”there is only venture capital. This, in a nutshell, is why the VC model works. By investing in many small companies and capping the downside in each through staging, its practitioners can manage uncertainty.

“Risk is when you know the odds, uncertainty is when you do not.”

More eloquently put then I’ve ever described it to myself or peers. I used to describe it as stress or anxiety. Or more accurately, and more of a mouthful, risks that cause stress versus risks that cause anxiety. Stress is caused by things that can be changed by the GP, by me, or by an individual if willing. Anxiety is caused by factors outside of anyone’s (especially my control). Stress is risk that can be mitigated by action and choice. Anxiety is “risk”, or in Frank’s words, uncertainty that has no immediate action items. And the paralysis of what to do next causes anxiety. Now these may sound like semantics, and probably are to most people. But to me, this influences if I, or any LP, can influence the GP to change. Or if it’s just undue pressure due to our own emotional state and fear over accepting uncertainty.

When doing diligence, a risk is a risk when the GP has a plan to overcome. An uncertainty is usually a risk deprioritized. Something the GP has not allocated calories to solve because there are bigger dragons to slay.

Now I should caveat that it is not in my job description to ever “change” a GP. If we choose to invest, we choose to invest in the kind of person they are and the kind of person they are willing to be (and be coached to be). If they’re not willing, then there’s very little any external person can do for anything to happen. And if there is something we can do, the juice may not be worth the squeeze.

Another important caveat that I wish more LPs were aware of. If there are additional conversations that requires favors from the GP, then I take stock of how much social capital (depth of relationship) I have with the GP, plus my check size relative to the fund size. The larger my check, the more allowance I have to ask for more time with the GP and/or ask for more intros to references. The deeper my existing relationship with the GP, the more I can spend time with them without seeming like an asshole. Although oftentimes if I know a GP well enough, I don’t really need additional time to suss out their character.

To add another layer of nuance, when I write down the initial risks of investing in the GP, I also characterize each risk and uncertainty as flaws, limitations, or restrictions. An homage to Brandon Sanderson. I’ve written at length about them here, but the TL;DR is:

  1. A flaw is something a GP needs to overcome within the next 3-5 years to become more established, or โ€œobviousโ€ to an LP, to founders, to co-investors, or simply to the world.
  2. Limitations are imposed by others or by the macro environment, often against their own will. These are sometimes optical illusions the broader world has convinced themselves of. While not something that the GPs can directly change, as an LP, you need to measure if any of the limitations impact a GP’s chances of outlier performance in a meaningful way. Also, limitations also include beliefs that you as the LP personally have about GPs you invest in.
  3. Restrictions, on the other hand, are self-imposed. Something a GP may need to overcome but chooses not to. For instance, Batman doesn’t kill. He could, but he doesn’t. A GP may choose to only invest in founders they can get along with. They don’t have to. They can invest in founders they don’t get along with but still make them money. It’s a choice.

If you couldn’t tell, I’m a nerd who likes to spell things out for myself… for clarity. You may not need the same degree of compartmentalization. And I will say a few of my peers realize the above hesitations purely in an intuitive sense. As Robert De Niro says in Ronin, “If there is any doubt, there is no doubt.”

I’m merely putting any reason to hesitate into words that I can describe the feeling I get, so that 10 years from now, and I look back at the decision, I can describe the why behind what could be a smart or dumb decision.

One last important note is that I enjoy spending most of my time underwriting emerging venture capital managers to invest in. And in doing so, GPs are always loaded with risks and uncertainties. If you say you shouldn’t invest, you are more likely to be right than wrong. But part of believing in the unproven (or pre-consensus) is that first word: believe. So despite the above soliloquy, one must never forget to have faith in people.

Photo by Juliana Malta on Unsplash


Stay up to date with the weekly cup of cognitive adventures inside venture capital and startups, as well as cataloging the history of tomorrow through the bookmarks of yesterday!


The views expressed on this blogpost are for informational purposes only. None of the views expressed herein constitute legal, investment, business, or tax advice. Any allusions or references to funds or companies are for illustrative purposes only, and should not be relied upon as investment recommendations. Consult a professional investment advisor prior to making any investment decisions.